Something to think about - How can solar panels and farming coexist?

NPR news released a story on solar panels and farming coexisting…with an example from Colorado. Check it out – with interesting reviews and comments by folks in Wisconsin’s northern regions. Sent to WNPJ by Langlade County <>

Full story and pictures here:


This Colorado 'solar garden' is literally a farm under solar panels

November 14, 2021

When Byron Kominek returned home after the Peace Corps and later working as a diplomat in Africa, his family's 24-acre farm near Boulder, Colo., was struggling to turn a profit.

"Our farm has mainly been hay producing for fifty years," Kominek said, on a recent chilly morning, the sun illuminating a dusting of snow on the foothills to his West. "This is a big change on one of our three pastures."

That big change is certainly an eye opener: 3,200 solar panels mounted on posts eight feet high above what used to be an alfalfa field on this patch of rolling farmland at the doorstep of the Rocky Mountains.

Getting to this point, a community solar garden that sells 1.2 megawatts of power back into the local grid, wasn't easy, even in a progressive county like his that wanted to expand renewable energy. When Kominek approached Boulder County regulators about putting up solar panels, they initially told him no, his land was designated as historic farmland.

"They said, land's for farming, so go farm it," Kominek says. "I said, well, we weren't making any money, you all want to be 100% renewable at some point so how about we work together and sort this out."

They eventually did, with help from researchers at nearby Colorado State University and the National Renewable Energy Lab, which had been studying how to turn all that otherwise unused land beneath solar panels into a place to grow food.

With close to two billion dollars devoted to renewable power in the newly passed infrastructure bill, the solar industry is poised for a win. But there have long been some tensions between renewable developers and some farmers. According to NREL, upwards of two million acres of American farmland could be converted to solar in the next decade.

But what if it didn't have to be an either or proposition? What if solar panels and farming could literally co-exist, if not even help one another.

That was what piqued Kominek's interest, especially with so many family farms barely hanging on in a world of corporate consolidation and so many older farmers nearing retirement.

Last year, Boulder County updated its land use code. And soon after Kominek installed the solar panels on one of this pastures. They're spaced far enough apart from one another so he could drive his tractor between them.

Still, when it came time to plant earlier this year, Kominek was initially skeptical.

But he soon discovered that the shade from the towering panels above the soil actually helped the plants thrive. That intermittent shade also meant a lot less evaporation of coveted irrigation water. And in turn the evaporation actually helped keep the sun-baked solar panels cooler, making them more efficient.

By summer, Kominek was a believer.

Walking the intricately lined rows of veggies beneath the panels, he beams pointing out where the peppers, tomatoes, squash, pumpkins, lettuces, beets, turnips, carrots were all recently harvested. The farm is still bursting with chard and kale even in November.

"Oh yeah, kale never dies," Kominek says, chuckling.

Kominek's farm, rebranded as Jack's Solar Garden (Jack is his grandfather's name), is part of a burgeoning industry known as agrivoltaics. It's a relatively new field of research and Kominek's farm is one of only about a dozen in the United States known to be experimenting with it.

But agrivoltaics is drawing particular interest in the West, now in the grips of a 22 year megadrought.

"Around the western US, water is the reason to go to war," says Greg Barron-Gafford, a University of Arizona professor who is considered one of the country's foremost experts in the field.

"Water is the reason we have to have real big arguments about where we're going to get our food from in the future," he says.

Barron-Gafford's research in the Arizona desert showed some crops grown underneath solar panels needed 50% less water. He and other scientists have their eyes on the infrastructure bill and are pushing to get some of the estimated $300 million included in it for new solar projects to go toward agrivoltaics.

"If you really want to build infrastructure in a way that is not going to compete with food and could actually take advantage of our dwindling resources in terms of water in a really efficient way, this is something to look at," Barron-Gafford says.

Researchers say there needs to be financial incentives for family farmers to add solar to their portfolio, if solar gardens like Byron Kominek's are really going to take off and become mainstream.

In Kominek's case, he literally bet the farm in order to finance the roughly $2 million solar arrays.

"We had to put up our farm as collateral as well as the solar array as collateral to the bank," he says. "If this doesn't work, we lose the farm."

But farming is all about taking on risk and debt, he says. And early on anyway, it's looking like his bet could pay off.

"That humming [you hear] is the inverters making us money," he says, pointing toward an electric converter box mounted near a row of kale. A series of wires carry the power out to the county highway and onto the local Xcel Energy grid.

The inverters here generate enough power for 300 homes to use in a year. Kominek hopes to soon grow enough food beneath the panels to maybe feed as many local families.




Related opportunity to comment:


Wisconsin Representative Jeff Mursau (far northeastern WI) asked a question this week about concerns over solar panels; taking up farm field space, devaluing property values, disturbance of ecosystems, chemical contamination, and electromagnetic waves. This same representative has never introduced legislation to stop large scale dairy CAFOs from dumping waste on bare farm fields that contaminates nearby private property owner's water wells. Mursau has also never introduced any legislation to protect his constituents from toxic mineral exploration and open-pit sulfide mine development. His region is also experiencing PFAS contamination. Again - no legislation by Mursau.


From Jeff Mursau's website:


Question of the Week: 
Solar Facilities on Farmland

Clean energy has become more and more popular in past decades, with solar panels being put on residential houses, businesses and large lots of land to generate electricity. However, with the increasing use of solar, there's also been concerns about the impact it has, particularly large-scale solar facilities. Often, solar companies will purchase large lots of farmland in order to set up these large solar facilities, with limited input or approval opportunities from the people living in the area. Under current law, if a project will generate more than 100 megawatts of electricity, it doesn't need approval from the local municipality. 

Supporters of these large-scale solar facilities say that they are doing their part to help preserve the environment by creating clean energy for the area. They say that these solar farms provide reliable, renewable energy without causing pollution, and say that the land can be still used for crop-land or grazing, or can easily be returned to regular agricultural purposes if desired.

Opponents of these large-scale solar facilities are concerned with the amount of farmland that they take out of rotation and causes nearby property values to plummet. In addition, the process of installing the facility and it's presence also disturbs local ecosystems. On top of that, there are concerns that the panels themselves will leak chemicals into the ground or that strong electromagnetic waves from the facility can harm those living nearby.

With the increasing use of solar energy, I would like to hear your thoughts on large solar facilities built on farmland. Please take a moment to answer my question of the week:

Click here for my Question of the Week